Some Thoughts on Why King v. Burwell Is Wrong, But Also, Maybe, Right

Occasionally, I’ll be sitting in church, and I’ll hear someone start dissecting the Bible like a piece of legislation: “Well, if Jesus meant ___, he wouldn’t have said ___, because then ___ would be superfluous.”  Or some similar thing. As a lawyer, I understand this impulse — and do my very best to resist it.  I think there is very little, if any, good that comes of trying to interpret scripture according to formalistic rules — rules that I can pretty guarantee that none of Moses, Isaiah, Jesus, Peter, or Paul…